Dodgy garages: how to complain and get what you want

Dodgy garages

Hard at work under the bonnet. Trouble is, you asked him to fix the suspension. Find out how to deal with a garage that doesn’t do what you asked

Thanks to a few dodgy traders, it’s reasonable to say garages don’t have the best reputation in the eyes of most car owners. The vast majority of mechanics are fair and honest. But over time, a small proportion have tarnished the industry’s image.

There are many ways you can end up out of pocket after dealing with a garage. They might damage your car while it’s in their care. They may charge you for work that you haven’t asked for. Or they might return your car with the problem fixed and another one introduced.

If you’re unlucky enough to encounter a problem with a garage, there are some steps you can take to ensure you don’t end up out of pocket. With the help of Citizens Advice we look at problems and solutions.

The problem: a garage overcharges you

If your car has a fault and you told the garage to fix it, you handed the right to decide what work needed to be done to the garage. You’ll have to pay for any work that was necessary. However, according to the 2015 Consumer Rights Act you only have to pay a reasonable price. Citizens Advices suggests you ask another garage to quote for the work so you can assess what is and isn’t a reasonable price.

The fix: You can avoid this aggravation by agreeing the price for a job beforehand. Get this as a written quotation. If you agree a price with the garage and it isn’t written down, you still have a contract with them. This cuts both ways. They can’t charge more, but you have to pay the price you agreed. Make sure any price you get is a ‘quotation’. Estimates are essentially a guess and they can go up.

The problem: a garage damages your car

When a garage agrees to repair your car, it has a responsibility to take reasonable care of it. And that doesn’t mean lending it to the apprentice so he can take his girlfriend out.

The fix: Even if the garage has a notice denying any responsibility for loss or damage to vehicles in their possession, you can still claim for damage. Again, your rights are protected under the 2015 Consumer Rights Act. You need to claim swiftly and point out any damage as soon as you see it. The answer is to take photographs of your car before the garage appointment so you have dated proof that the damage occurred in the garage.

The problem: a garage does work you didn’t ask for

If you asked the garage to do a specific piece of work such as changing the oil and filter, and it put in new filters for the fuel and air as well, you can ask it to undo the work. If that isn’t possible you can insist you only pay for the work you asked for.

The fix: Again, agree what needs to be done in writing so there can be no discrepancy between what you think should be done and what the garage does.

The problem: you’re not getting anywhere

If you are unhappy with work carried out, you should take up the matter with the garage. However, you may not be able to agree a reasonable way forwards. If that’s the case, you need to get your car back.

The fix: Pay for the work but on the garage’s copy of the paperwork, write ‘Paying under protest’. You can then seek compensation. First see if the garage belongs to any trade association such as Motor Codes. If it doesn’t, ask if it belongs to an Alternative Dispute Resolution scheme. If the answer’s no again, you could go to the small claims court.

The problem: the garage lied to you

If the garage has been economical with the truth or misled you in any way, including claiming it’s carried out work which it hasn’t done, complain to Trading Standards.

The fix: Under the Consumer Protection from Unfair Trading Regulations 2008 (CPR) the above are offences and you can legitimately complain and seek redress against the garage.

3 comments on “Dodgy garages: how to complain and get what you want

  1. Jonathon 11/07/2019 5:11 PM

    took my car to my local garage as the exhaust was literally hanging off. They have had to replace both middle and back section. i have to go back in the morning as a rear bracket for the back box has corroded away. Given my car was MOT’d barely 3 months ago i don’t understand as to why it still passed the MOT given this was flagged up at pre MOT check as to be regarded as a major fault that needed to be rectified straight away. i am not a garage man but i don’t beleive that something could corrode in the space of 3 month to the extent that it falls off, especially when this was supposed to be repaired?

  2. Nthabiseng 01/10/2020 8:42 PM

    I took my car for clush and I got changed 1800 later the guy called me saying he needs 450 for oil, change me for removing my stater and putting it back. And now my car is leaking water and the clush moto is making a sound. I spent 5000 just to fix a i10 clush and now I still have to fine some one to fix the clush moto and leaking water… Please help

  3. Iqbal 21/01/2023 8:42 PM

    My Vauxhall Zafira 2017 auto 1.4 turbo broke down while I was driving ,I have called RAC and RAC said its turbo problem ,I was towed up to 10 miles where I found a garage closed to my place.I have asked the mechanic if he can changed the turbo for me but he price was too high then finally agreed for a second hand for £600.I dropped the car went home after 10 mins the mechanic called me to put a deposit I have transferred £300 then after 2 mins he called back he said its my engine problem not turbo so its more likely the piston problem.He agree to changed for £1200.
    When I pick up the car,he gave a fake invoice ,he changed only 1 turbo.
    I have contacted Trading standards, I was giving to advice to write to him but the letter return back to me as the garage does not registered as the name given on the invoice but the address is correct.
    Trading Standard won’t help because of the garage does not have a name.
    Now the car is causing to much problem, everytime I’m driving the engine management light on ,it’s says loss power and heavy noise.
    I switch off the engine and restart after 10 mins so that I can drive but the noise still there..
    The garage not helping even I was going 6 months warranty.
    Any advice please

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>