Car insurance premiums: why you’re paying more than ever for cover

Car insurance rises to record high average cost

Drivers of all ages are paying record amounts in car insurance premiums. And the Association of British Insurers (ABI) has warned there is no end in sight for the high cost of cover.

The reason for these spiralling prices is a cocktail of external factors. Here we look at why the cost of cover is going up, show where premiums are spent, and point the way to how drivers can save money on their motor insurance.

What’s the average price of UK car insurance?

According to the ABI’s latest figures, all age groups over 21 have experienced rising costs over the last 12 months. While younger drivers’ premiums are being kept under control by the increasing use of telematics, they’re in the minority. Drivers in their late 50s and late 80s faced the highest rises last year – nearly £35 per annum. The average annual premium is now £462. That’s up by £33 or 8 per cent compared with the same period last year.

However, independent price comparison company Confused.com says the cost is greater still. It has been tracking the average cost of insurance for every quarter since 2006. In 2017, it says drivers have faced average car insurance bills of £781 a year. Confused.com claims that’s a rise of £110, or 16 per cent on the previous year.

Why is car insurance so expensive?

Insurers have found themselves hit by a triple whammy of influencing factors. First is the compensation culture and bogus personal injury claims. In 2015, the ABI says there were 69,000 fraudulent motor claims made, costing £780 million.

The second area to have an impact on insurance costs is the complexity of modern cars. Increasingly sophisticated electronics require specialist equipment and training to be fitted and calibrated. Even simple body panel parts are becoming more expensive due to the weak pound. Over the last three years, the average repair bill has risen by 32 per cent, to £1678, according to the ABI.

Last but definitely not least is the increase in insurance premium tax. Until 2015, it was 6 per cent. But it has been steadily increased by the government to 10 per cent. It will go up again, to 12 per cent, this June.

What are car insurance premiums spent on?

Car insurance premiums

The Association of British Insurers produced the graphic above to show how drivers’ premiums are spent by insurers. The ABI also points out that Insurance Premium Tax is on top of this.

Is there light at the end of the tunnel?

If only there was. Earlier in the year, the government introduced reforms to put the brakes on whiplash claims. This was expected to lower car insurance premiums by an average of £40.

However, changes to personal injury compensation rules could negate that. Previously, courts took 2.5 per cent off any compensation pay out awarded to individuals. It was done to reflect the interest a victim will earn on the lump sum when they put it in the bank.

But after late March, the rate was changed to minus 0.75 per cent. This was to reflect the fact that interest rates are so low for consumers.

However, it means insurers could end up raising prices by an average of £75 a year, according to Price Waterhouse Coopers, the accountancy firm. And the ABI has described the decision as ‘crazy’. ABI director general Huw Evans said: “With inflation on the rise, motor premiums at a record high and the public purse under pressure, it’s concerning that the government has yet to commit to delivering a fairer system for setting the personal injury discount rate. We’re pleased the government is going to bring forward a Civil Liability Bill to reform whiplash style personal injury compensation. But the benefits could be wiped out if they don’t defuse the discount rate bomb.”

How can drivers reduce their insurance costs?

Read our guide to cutting the cost of car insurance premiums.  This offers advice on areas including shopping around, picking a car with a competitive insurance rating and keeping the car garaged.

Buy Green Flag cover at half the price of your AA or RAC renewal quote. Save 50% (For vehicles 10 years and under on our closest equivalent UK cover.)

12 comments on “Car insurance premiums: why you’re paying more than ever for cover

  1. John Green September 7, 2017 9:37 am

    Thanks to Green Flag for helping to keep my motoring costs down

  2. Robert Henry September 8, 2017 3:01 pm

    Rip off Britain – again!

  3. T.L.Ricketts September 9, 2017 9:01 am

    Why doesn’t NO claims Bonus count for anything these days? I have driven 52 years without a claim but still my premiums keep going up

  4. david jones September 9, 2017 9:14 am

    I see the government take a nice slice of the cake without us knowing and they have certainly got to sort out the compensation culture.

  5. Lee Heightley September 9, 2017 4:13 pm

    young people out to scam the older generation in my case

  6. Sylvia Woods September 11, 2017 7:07 am

    Always the consumer that has to fork out!

  7. N.Kaye September 11, 2017 12:52 pm

    It is high time the insurance companies started to confine higher prices to those drivers who make the claims and to leave alone those who do not. With modern technology sorting those who do from those who do not would be a doddle.

  8. Eric Chapman September 12, 2017 6:58 pm

    My van insurance has tripled. No comment.

  9. Andy Irvine September 13, 2017 9:17 am

    Blame your government not the Insurers! The reduction in the discount rate to 0.75 and raise in the IPT (Stealth tax) to 12% has had a major impact on costs to the consumer. Wait for the next kick as IPT goes up to match VAT rate! Its going to happen!

  10. Arthur Cross September 14, 2017 6:57 am

    Another reason for high costs is the number of companies involved when making a claim, I am waiting for my claim to be sorted since December 2016, there have been six different companies involved who will all want a slice of the pie, and who pays for that?? Me!!!
    Absolutely ridiculous , and still waiting.

  11. steve burstow September 15, 2017 1:26 pm

    If the Government negotiated an overall rate for the legally required third party insurance and included that in the road tax it would guarantee that every driver was legally insured at an affordable rate and that the insurance companies would have to be very competitive in arranging premiums for comprehensive cover.

  12. Jim whitfield September 18, 2017 7:10 pm

    We all know that garages inflate the bill if it’s an insurance claim I have been asked a few times is it insurance or your bill
    Our beloved Volvo v70 was smashed into in a McDonald’s car park and was written by was written off by the insurance company due to a stupidly quote from a Volvo garage. I said no way and got the car back and repaired for a fraction of the cost

Leave a Reply